Our Signature Pizzas
For over 35 years, Joe's Brooklyn Pizza has perfected the art of authentic New York-style pizza. Each pie is crafted with traditional techniques passed down through generations, using only the finest quality ingredients. We believe in doing pizza right—no gimmicks, no shortcuts, just genuine Brooklyn flavor in every bite.
Classic Cheese
The foundation of great pizza. Our signature cheese pizza features a perfectly balanced blend of premium mozzarella on a hand-stretched dough crust, topped with our secret-recipe tomato sauce. Crispy on the outside, pliable on the inside—the Brooklyn way.
Pepperoni Perfection
Our most popular pie. Premium pepperoni with perfectly crispy edges, layered over rich mozzarella and our signature sauce. The pepperoni cups slightly as it cooks, creating those coveted crispy edges that make each bite unforgettable. This is what pizza dreams are made of.
Specialty Selections
Beyond the classics, we offer carefully crafted specialty pizzas that honor Brooklyn tradition while celebrating quality ingredients. Fresh vegetables, premium meats, and thoughtful combinations—each pizza tells a story of culinary passion and respect for the craft.
Ask our team about today's specialty offerings and seasonal recommendations.
Available for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Mon-Thu 11am-8pm
Complete Your Order
Round out your pizza experience with our carefully selected sides and beverages—the perfect complement to authentic Brooklyn pizza.
Garlic Knots
Crispy, golden knots brushed with fragrant garlic oil and fresh parsley. A Brooklyn pizzeria essential.
Perfect as an appetizer or side
Buffalo Wings
Crispy wings tossed in classic buffalo sauce. Served with blue cheese dressing for dipping.
Great for sharing
Fresh Salads
Garden fresh greens with quality dressings. A lighter option to balance your pizza meal.
Caesar, Italian, and Greek varieties
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded and fried until golden. Gooey, stretchy mozzarella in every bite.
Served with marinara sauce
Cold Beverages
Classic sodas, iced tea, and refreshing drinks to wash down your pizza.
Cans and bottles available
Sweet Treats
End your meal on a sweet note with our selection of classic desserts.
Cannoli and more
Family Meal Deals
Feeding a crowd? Our family combos bring everything you need for a complete pizza night—save money when you order together.
Ask about our catering options for larger groups and special events.
Open Mon–Thu, 11am–8pm | 1918 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618